Both are control panels for a web server: files, databases, mailboxes, DNS, certificates, PHP versions and backups, behind a login instead of a command line. The arguments between them are mostly habit, and the parts that are not are easy to state.
What is genuinely different
- Operating system. cPanel runs on Linux. Plesk runs on Linux or Windows, so a site that needs ASP.NET or MSSQL is a Plesk question rather than a cPanel one.
- How the interface is organised. cPanel separates the account from the server administration, with WHM over the top. Plesk puts both in one interface with different permissions. Neither is better; they suit different habits.
- Licensing. Both are commercial and both are priced per server or per account. On our shared plans the licence is already included. On a VPS the licence is not included and we do not sell one: a virtual server is handed over with no control panel on it, and a panel you want there is one you licence and install yourself.
What is not different
Both will create a site, issue a certificate, make a mailbox, give you a database and a user, schedule a cron job, show you a log and take a backup. If a tutorial tells you one of them cannot do something ordinary, check its date.
Our answer
Every shared hosting plan here is cPanel, and the licence is in the price. We did not pick it because it wins an argument; we picked one so that every account on every server works the same way, which is worth more to the people we support than the difference between the two panels.
On a VPS the choice, and the licence, are yours. Ask us first if you are unsure whether the plan has the memory for the panel you have in mind, because a control panel is a substantial piece of software before your site has used anything at all.
If you are moving from one to the other
Both can import from the other, and both do it better with the original server still running. Copy the site across, test it on the new panel while the old one still serves visitors, and change DNS last. The step people get wrong is pointing the domain first and then discovering what did not come over.